| YEAR |
WINNER |
| 2007 |
KRIS KASH vs. "THE FUTURE" SHANE STARR |
| 2006 |
"THE ENFORCER" SHAWN BLANCHARD vs. LA LUCHA |
| 2005 |
"DR. DEVASTATION" LOU MARTIN vs. "THE ENFORCER" SHAWN BLANCHARD |
| 2004 |
"DR. DEVASTATION" LOU MARTIN, "THE ENFORCER" SHAWN BLANCHARD, THE LATIN ASSASSIN, "MR. TENACITY" TOMMY FAIME & "THE SINGLE THREAT" DEL DOUGLAS
vs.
ANTHONY ALEXANDER, MIKE MALACHI, "MR. PUNIVERSE" BOB ATLAS, JUSTIN SANE & BOBBY O |
| 2003 |
"DR. DEVASTATION" LOU MARTIN & "THE ENFORCER" SHAWN BLANCHARD
vs.
THE PRIME TIME PLAYERS & JUSTIN SANE |
| 2002 |
MIKE MALACHI
vs.
KSWA (BATTLE FOR RESPECT) |
| 2001 |
"THE ENFORCER" SHAWN BLANCHARD
vs.
"MR. TENACITY" TOMMY FAIME |